Last year, I
had focused on the “best” movies of each decade. I was asked by someone to make a separate
list of “favorite” movies, but to this point I’ve been too busy to really get
to it. Now, I’m going to try to get
these out a little by little.
There’s a couple of differences. For my favorites, I decided to go by genre rather than decade, because it makes more sense to me. Part of what kept me from working on this was trying to figure out what genre some movies fit in, since that can be a bit vague. So, I decided that some movies will count as multiple genres. That also means that my ranking of those movies might not be consistent, because I might favor a certain movie more in one genre than another.
The other thing is that my favorite is much more subjective and dependent on how I feel at that time. Why? Because I am basically ranking these as “which movie would I rather watch.” This is difficult, because I might want to watch one movie at one point and another at another point. So, I am trying to look at these as “in general, which movie would I rather watch.”
Finally, some have asked me in confusion what the difference is between “best” and “favorite.” For me, it’s a huge difference. Just because a movie is better, doesn’t mean it’s a favorite. For instance, Schindler’s List is definitely one of the best movies ever made (quality), but it’s nowhere near a favorite movie, because I have to be in a very specific mood to watch it. At the same time, just because a movie is a favorite of mine doesn’t mean it’s great. Armageddon is one of my favorite science fiction movies (a “guilty pleasure”) but I know it’s not a great movie. It’s just fun and nostalgic for me. Oh, also, these favorite lists will not be restricted to a certain number, just what I decide on because I can.
For this
particular list, I’m starting with Westerns.
Why? Partly because it’s one of
my favorite genres. Partly because it’s
random. Partly because my original
intent this year was, while last year I watched movies each month based on the
decade, this year I was going to decade each month to a genre. That didn’t happen, except that in September
I was watching and listening to a lot of Westerns because I could.
With a lot of
ado, but no further ado, here is my list in descending order, of my favorite
Westerns.
1. Tombstone
(1993)
I had a really hard time picking a favorite, and
nearly went with #2, but this movie is just so great it transcends the
genre. I feel like even people who don’t
like Westerns can like Tombstone. Why is
it so great? It starts with the amazing
cast. And while many people first point
to Val Kilmer, Kurt Russell makes this movie my favorite. The script is great and so many memorable
lines. The score is fantastic. It looks great. All around, a movie I will never get tired of
watching. There may be better Westerns,
but this is my favorite.
2. Maverick
(1994)
So nearly chose this #1, because it is also one of my
favorite comedies. But when I think of
Western, I think more of Tombstone, so I had to put that first. The cast is great. I love Mel Gibson in this, but Graham Greene
steals the show. It is hilarious,
especially the Indian interlude. Yes,
they go a bit too far with the love story, but I can fast forward through that
to enjoy the rest of it. Plus, the Danny
Glover cameo is one of the best of all time.
3. The
Searchers (1956)
This is the greatest Western of all time, and it’s not
even close. When I think of Western,
this is the first that comes to mind.
But as far as favorite, it’s just a tick below the first two. That being said, I feel so lucky to have been
able to see it on the big screen, with my dad, a number of years ago. John Wayne is fantastic, and John Ford is at
his peak.
4. The
Alamo (Director’s Cut) (1960)

Speaking of John Wayne, it’s a shame that there is not
a “legit” way to purchase the Director’s Cut (Roadshow Version) of this movie
right now, because it is far better than the shorter cut that is the norm
now. Plus, how can you not love this
classic Texas story?
5. Dances
with Wolves (1990)
It’s a great movie, and definitely better in it’s
longer Director’s Cut, but as a “favorite” it is another step down from the
others. And, again, an unfortunate sex
scene, though it can be easily skipped.
6. Fort
Apache/She Wore A Yellow Ribbon/Rio Grande (1948/1949/1950)
It’s impossible to separate these movies, the John
Ford/John Wayne cavalry trilogy. All
really good and really worth watching.
Fort Apache is probably my favorite of them, because it’s so easy to
love to hate Henry Fonda in it.
7. The
Magnificent Seven (1960)
One of the best Western scores of all time, and a
great cast, and a timeless story (though, of course, it’s a remake of The Seven
Samurai, but it’s much better in my opinion).
It’s hard not to love Yul Brynner, Steve McQueen, Charles Bronson, James
Coburn, and the gang.
8. Geronimo:
An American Legend (1993)
It’s unfortunate that this movie does not get more
credit for as good a movie as it is. Wes
Studi is fantastic, and the rest of the cast is great. A wonderful call back to the John Ford
cavalry movies.
9. Open
Range (2003)
Kevin Costner and Robert Duvall are so good
together. The final shoot-out is
great. It would be higher, but the
middle drags just a touch on re-watch.
10. The
Man from Snowy River (1982)
An Australian Western makes the list. It’s a really good story about hard work and
determination. And, like most of these,
the score is great.
11. Big
Jake (1971)
Old John Wayne is still an incredible tough guy. You just don’t mess with him.
12. The
Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962)
Perhaps a bit slow, but the cast is so good that you
don’t mind it.
13. The
Paleface/Son of Paleface (1948/1952)
Bob Hope brings lots of laughs to the West.
14. True
Grit (2010)
Blasphemy for some, but this is much better than the
John Wayne version because the rest of the cast is significantly better.
15. Red
River (1948)
A great movie, but I rarely think “I need to watch
that again.”
16. Dodge
City (1939)
Errol Flynn and Olivia de Havilland belong more in the
Robin Hood days, but this is a fun Western that has everything. It’s like they decided to include every
Western cliché, but before they became cliches.
That’s not a bad thing.
17. Silverado
(1985)
Yes, Costner is strong on this list. A fun cast and a good story.
18. Stagecoach
(1939)
It would be higher on a list of “best,” but it’s a bit
dry, which drops it in my favorites.
19. 3:10
to Yuma (2007)
With a recent re-watch, this actually fell down in my
favorite list because I just wasn’t feeling it as much as I had before. Still, the cast is great, particularly Ben
Foster.
20. 3
Godfathers (1948)
It’s a Christmas (actually Epiphany) Western with John
Wayne!
I decided to cut the list there, but there are others that
deserve mention. True Grit (1969)
suffers from a way too old Kim Darby and an annoying Glen Campbell. Return to Snowy River (1988) is a decent
sequel. The Man with No Name Trilogy
(1964-1966) is good, but never one of my favorites. Sons of Katie Elder (1965), Cahill United
States Marshall (1973), El Dorado (1966), Angel and the Badman (1947), and Rio
Lobo (1970) are just a few Wayne movies worth watching. An American Tail: Fievel Goes West (1991) is
a really fun animated love-letter to Westerns. Wyatt Earp (1994) is ok, but
really long and it rushes the best part of Earp’s life. High Noon (1952) is extremely overrated. There are plenty of other Westerns that are
not worth mentioning.
Favorite Western Scores (it’s fascinating, nearly every
great composer has scored a Western, and they’re all some of their best work)
Tombstone (Bruce Broughton – if I were to make a Western, I would want him to score it)
Dances With Wolves (John Barry)
Silverado (Bruce Broughton)
True Grit (Carter Burwell)
The Man From Snowy River/Return to Snowy River (Bruce
Rowland)
The Magnificent Seven (Elmer Bernstein)
Maverick (Randy Newman)
Geronimo: An American Legend (Ry Cooder)
The Alamo (Dimitri Tiomkin)
The Searchers (Max Steiner)
Wyatt Earp (James Newton Howard)
Open Range (Michael Kamen)
An American Tail: Fievel Goes West (James Horner)
Lonesome Dove (Basil Poledouris)
The Man With No Name Trilogy (Ennio Morricone)
The Cowboys (John Williams)
Horizon: An American Saga, Chapter 1 (John Debney)
3:10 to Yuma (Marco Beltrami)
