Wednesday, November 11, 2015

Remembering Remembrance Day

Hopefully no one reading this has to be told why today is important.  97 years ago, Germany agreed to an Armistice to end the Great War.  Around the world, we remember those who fought with Armistice Day, or Remembrance Day, or Veteran's Day. 


In light of this, I wanted to shed some light on movies depicting the Great War.  For some reason, this war has been largely overlooked, particularly when compared to the Second World War.  Nevertheless, there are some good ones out there.  I am looking at these as World War I movies, not just as movies themselves.  Hence, the ranking here might not reflect how good they are in a general category of movies.

1.  Paths of Glory (1957)

            One of only two Stanley Kubrick movies (Spartacus) that I recommend.  It is a haunting look at some of the issues that go on behind the scenes in war.  As a strictly anti-war film, it is almost more like a Vietnam movie, though it was made well before Vietnam was a full-blown conflict for Americans.

2.  All Quiet on the Western Front (1930)

            Based on the quintessential World War I book, it also has a strong anti-war bent.  It is particularly adept at showing the influence of propaganda.

3.  Lawrence of Arabia (1962)

            The best movie on the list, it's a few notches down since it is only tangentially connected to the greater war.  Still, it is a good look at an area of the war that is sometimes forgotten though perhaps most relevant for us today, given the importance of Arabia and the former Ottoman Empire.

4.  Sergeant York (1941)

            Yes, there is a bit of camp, but I still like this depiction of the war.  It's the only truly pro-war movie on this list (if you can't tell from the poster), so for that it is more like a World War II movie (which makes sense given its release date).  Surprisingly little of the movie actually takes place during the war, which maybe is appropriate given how little America played a role in it.

5.  War Horse (2011)

            What some people call overly sentimental, I call an interesting look at the war from multiple angles.  The horse charge is a dramatic example of the changing modernity of war during this time.

6.  Legends of the Fall (1994)

            Perhaps the movie on this list where the war is least important, but still it shows the effect war can have on a family.  A good movie, despite Brad Pitt (I say that quite a bit).  I might add that, as much as I love John Williams' score for War Horse, this has by far the best score on the list.

7.  Passchendaele (2010)

            The only truly bad movie on this list.  Poorly made, poorly acted, and few war scenes.  At least Canada tried.

Of note:  I grew up loving The Young Indiana Jones Chronicles, particularly the episodes during the war, both in Europe and in Africa.  For a TV show, it's still pretty good.

Movies I need to see:
Joyeaux Noel (heard many good things about it)
Wings (the first Best Picture Oscar winner)

Gallipoli (with Mad Max a movie that put Mel Gibson on the map)

1 comment:

  1. Gallipoli is really good. Takes a bit to get to the battle, but it's worth the ride. Builds the two main characters. Wings, not bad for such an early picture and the air combat is really amazing especially when you consider when it was filmed. Early part for Gary Cooper too in a small role.

    ReplyDelete